Showing posts with label editing. Show all posts
Showing posts with label editing. Show all posts

Monday, August 31, 2026

Thoughts on Writing by Nancy L. Eady

The quote, the way I heard it, was “All writers hate writing; all writers love having written,” attributed to Gloria Steinem. Today, a little investigation courtesy of Google has revealed that  the quote is attributed to Dorothy Parker in its original form, which was “I hate writing. I love having written.” Even further investigation, however, shows that no record exists proving Dorothy Parker ever said or wrote the quote attributed to her. 

Regardless of who said it, I disagree. I admit I have days when writing is a chore, when it is all I can do to keep my fingers typing out words, while my brain keeps encouraging me with helpful comments like, “This is the worst writing you’ve ever done.” But there are other days, too. Days when I enter “the zone,” and the words fly from my fingers to the screen, barely keeping up with my brain. It feels like flying. On those days, writing is not a chore. 

The other fallacy in the statement is that each author has individual preferences for what they like about the writing process. Some people love writing the first draft but suffer through the editing that comes next. Other people struggle to crank out the first draft but love the magic they find in the editing process, as they sculpt their raw material into a polished, readable work. And there are others, nuts like me, who have days and times when they enjoy both. 

Writing and editing remind me of counted cross-stitch, a craft I enjoy. In counted cross-stitch, the crafter takes a fabric such as linen or Aida, with a regular, discernible weave to it, chooses a chart of a picture marked up with symbols to stand for certain colors of thread, and then builds the picture on the fabric with tiny “x” stitches by following the chart. I love the building block process of counted cross-stitch, when I’m filling in the basic colors as indicated in the chart. But there is also magic in the finishing details, when back-stitching (a way of stitching straight lines) is used to create additional perspective based upon what structures in the picture are outlined, and in what colors. Writing the rough draft of a story or novel is like filling in the basic building blocks in cross-stitch, and editing adds the finishing details that make the story a marketable project. 

There are parts of writing as a business that I have found few, if any, writers love. “I am writing a synopsis today,” said no writer with glee ever. However, the one solid, basic fact you learn in law school is that every rule has an exception, so I’m sure someone is reading this post in disbelief, thinking “But, Nancy, don’t you know the synopsis is the best part?” 

All of which leads me to wonder, fellow readers, what you think of the quote. Do you hate writing but love having written? Do you prefer bringing that first draft into the world, or is your favorite part when you edit that first draft repeatedly to make it the best work you can present? Or is there some other part of writing that you cherish more? 


Monday, March 23, 2026

Editing Aids by Nancy L. Eady

 I have two programs I use to help me edit. For my legal writing, I like to use a program called WordRake. For my creative writing, I use ProWritingAid (just the regular version, not the AI version. AI still freaks me out.) They work differently. 

WordRake highlights words and phrases it wants me to omit or change from whatever draft I turn it loose on. It and I have a slightly antagonistic relationship, although I am always amused when the parts of my work that WordRake lights up like New York on a dark winter’s night are direct quotes from appellate cases. (Hey, we all get our kicks somewhere!) I also enjoy arguing with it about its editing selections. I don’t follow its suggestions mindlessly. 

My relationship with WordRake is similar to my mother’s first experience with a GPS. We were visiting Boston, and I rented a car with a GPS system. It was my first experience with GPS, which should give you an idea how long ago this was. My mom (who grew up in Boston) loved to ride with me and have me program the GPS. Then she would tell me the GPS was wrong and direct me to go a different way, giving the GPS a heart attack. At one point, it got so frustrated it stopped giving directions and churned through “recalculating” for about five minutes! However, I am more considerate of WordRake. Sometimes, I agree to its edits just because I don’t want to hurt its feelings by ignoring it too much.

My relationship with ProWritingAid is more of a collaboration. It is not as authoritative in its suggestions as WordRake. ProWritingAid scans a piece of writing and then assigns a score to different aspects of it, like a score for grammar, style, overused words, and sentence length. The program gives you a suggested benchmark to aim for, and while it takes you through the reasons behind the score it gave, you have the freedom to choose which areas to work on and how. 

Both programs have a place. Legal writing can be ponderous if you don’t pay careful attention to what you do, and WordRake keeps that in check. ProWritingAid follows the flow of creative writing, recognizing that each creative writer is different, yet there are pitfalls we all seek to avoid. 

Do you have an editing program you prefer to use with your writing? 


Monday, July 22, 2024

Grammar by Nancy L. Eady

To me, grammar is a funny looking word. It is one letter away from being a palindrome – a word that is spelled the same forwards and backwards. It would be “grammarg” if some enterprising person wanted to change it to fit the palindrome mold. If you were trying to guess how to spell “grammar” without ever having seen it, the most likely first guess would be “grammer.” A person who studies and writes about grammar is called a “grammarian.” I am not such a person. 

I have a decent grasp of the basics of grammar, such as what is a noun, verb, adjective and adverb. (Those of you who, like me, are of a certain age, probably can’t think of the word “adverb” without hearing a song in your head that begins “Lolly, lolly, lolly, get your adverbs here.” Thank you, Schoolhouse Rock!) I remember from my school years that a preposition is something that we are not supposed to end sentences or phrases with, except that now it is okay to do so. Or, as Winston Churchill said once when criticized by a young proofreader on ending a sentence with a preposition, “This is the type of arrant pedantry up with which I will not put.” 

The best way to learn about the grammar of your language is to study another language. It wasn’t until I began learning Spanish that I realized the wide variety of verb tenses that exist. According to Google, English has twelve verb tenses: simple present tense, present continuous, present perfect, present perfect continuous, past simple, past continuous, past perfect tense, and past perfect continuous, future simple, future continuous tense, future perfect, and future perfect continuous tense. But at the same time, there is also the “participle” form of a verb, which is when a verb has a “-ing” thrown on it. My best guess is that the participle is folded within the continuous tenses, past, present, future.  I remember the phrase “present participle” because when we finally reached it in basic Spanish, I thought, “Huh, I didn’t know we had that.” 

I always despised English tests that involved grammar questions. They most often consisted of one sentence written incorrectly, with four choices from which you had to select the correct sentence. When I would read the sentences, I could think of several ways to communicate the same sentiment more effectively, but none of those would be in the four choices.

All that being said, grammar is important. A writers’ job is to communicate. If you attempt to communicate in English without following the basic rules English speakers use, chances are you will not succeed. Or, if the mistake is something like using the plural form of a verb with the single form of a noun, the reader will understand what you mean but the mistake will jar the reader out of your work. 

Most writers understand the rules of grammar at an instinctual level. We have a feeling for what is “good writing” versus “poor writing” and grammar plays an important role in that evaluation. But I have never diagrammed a sentence and if you held a gun to me, I still couldn’t name all twelve English verb tenses in spite of having written them out three paragraphs above. That doesn’t mean I’m not grateful for those warriors out there who do make the study of grammar their business. After all, someone needs to keep track of the rules! 

How much did you study grammar before writing? Have you ever diagrammed a sentence? What kind of grammar mistakes do you look for in your editing?  


Saturday, May 25, 2024

The Long and Winding Road by Kait Carson

 Last month I shared my thoughts on the blessings and curses of being a full-time writer. When I stop to think about it, I realize that no matter what, I’m living my dream. I’ve wanted to be a writer for as long as I can remember. The good, the bad, the ugly, it’s exactly what I want to do with my life.

 Editing. That’s a different story. Don’t get me wrong. I love editing. It’s where the dog’s breakfast of the first draft becomes a cordon bleu meal. It’s fun, it’s entertaining, it’s surprising, and if it’s a new book that is intended to be first in a series, it takes forever! Or maybe forty forevers. I’m still working through that.

 The immediate world (and certainly my blog family) all know that the woman who used the email name DiverMiss since the inception of email services is now writing a thriller set in the north Maine woods. Yes, it was a transition capable of giving DiverMiss a bad case of the bends. Be that as it may, I’m a Mainer now. I wanted to pay homage to my adopted state. Since I’m also what tropical divers call a warm water wimp, there was no way that homage would include underwater activities. Instead, I turned to my second love – the woods.

 
My great-grandparents had a farm in upstate New York, and I’m lucky enough to have memories of that special place. Anyone familiar with upstate New York knows that it is (or was) heavily wooded. My male cousins took advantage of that to drive my mother crazy. Mom wanted me to be a girly girl. That didn’t work out. First, there were my cousins who had me in the woods before I was out of high-top leather shoes. They taught me to fish, track, build fires, camp, and survive in any weather. Trust me, my cousins made Outward Bound feel like a relaxing vacation. Then there was my home neighborhood. I was the only girl. If I wanted to play, it wasn’t going to be with dolls.

 Rural Maine felt like home, and I knew I wanted to set my next book in the woods. My house is surrounded by them. In fact, if you walk a straight line from my back door, you won’t see paved road until you swim the St. Lawrence and power-walk your way to Quebec. There are some camps (Mainers’ name for rural cabins) and maybe some abandoned logging camps, but that’s all. It’s a magical place. And the perfect setting for a murder mystery. I grabbed it, sat down and wrote a novel.

 I won’t lie. With the Florida mysteries, I’m mostly a two-draft writer. I know my setting and the ins and outs of my story. Things are different when you change settings, characters, and I won’t even mention the law enforcement aspects. Writing the first draft took a year. The book came in at 60,000 words. Not unusual for one of my first drafts. Then came the editing. That was where things changed. When I performed my first read-through I ended up with more questions than resolutions. That meant more research. Oh, and there were several plot holes large enough to drive a loaded logging truck through. That meant isolating and drafting a synopsis for each plot point. Several went the way of the circular file. The rest were vamped or revamped until the loose ends were all tied up. That meant more words.

 At this point, I’ve been working on this novel—tentatively titled No Return—for a year and nine months. The bad news—I’m still editing. The good news—I’m almost ready to type the two most glorious words in the English language, THE END. How will I know when I’m done? Easy. I’m ten chapters away from my next (last) read-through. The book is at 70,000 words and the plot holes have been filled. Barring a catastrophe, all that remains is a final pacing check and finding those pesky typos that multiply while I sleep. It has been a long road. Almost as long as the road from the Florida Keys to Fort Kent, Maine.

 Writers, do you find writing is slower when you change settings and characters? Readers, are you willing to follow authors into a new series?

Kait Carson writes the Hayden Kent Mysteries set in the beautiful Florida Keys. She lives in the north Maine woods with her husband, four cats, a flock of conures and a cavapoo puppy. All rescues.



Monday, April 29, 2024

How to Write a Novel by Nancy L. Eady

Two of WWK’s recent blog posts, one on April 12 by Heather Weidner, and one on April 27 by Kait Carson, got me thinking about how to write a novel. Their posts were more about how to get back into a regular writing schedule, but I realized that a tangent to their points is a simple principle: How do you write a novel? One word at a time. 

Think about it. If you never write the first word of the novel, you can never write the last word of the novel. And if you stop writing words somewhere in the middle, then all you are left with is a half-finished novel. So, in many ways, butt-in-chair-fingers-on-keyboard remains the central core of any writing regime. Unless you still write long-hand, in which case you have to keep pen on paper for similar periods of time, or unless you like to sit somewhere outdoors to do your writing, in which case your derriere will be sitting either on a lawn chair or a rock or a hill with your back against your tree or…. Well, you get the idea. But no matter what, your keyboard or your pen must continue to plunk out words until you come to the end. 

Notice, I did not title this blog “How to Write a Successful Novel,” which would be silly for me to write since I have yet to have my book published. But I did complete one book and have started a couple more since then, so I can authoritatively discuss what it takes to write a novel. While “writing one word at a time” as a guide to writing a novel is a bit of an oversimplification, since you also need something to write about (an idea), and characters that you enjoy writing about, but without the words, the idea and the characters won’t get much traction. And I have good news – sometimes when I have pounded out words just to keep going, thinking at the time I was putting out my worst writing ever, I later discovered when I re-read it that what I had written was better than originally thought.

Also note that the “one word at a time” theory does not apply to polished novels. What you get with the “one word at a time” approach is a finished novel you must then edit. But again, if you never finish the first draft, you will never have anything to edit. (A word of caution here – try to resist the temptation to edit any part of your novel until it is finished. Otherwise, you can get stuck editing Chapter 1 repeatedly to make it perfect, and never reach Chapter 2, let alone “the end.”) 

If you’re disenchanted with the amount of writing you’ve been able to get done lately, take heart! Promise yourself that you will take fifteen minutes to start putting words on a page. I’m willing to bet that before you know it, a lot more than fifteen minutes and a lot more than just a few words will pass by. 

What thoughts do you have that you use to encourage yourself or others to keep writing? What tricks do you use to get the small voice that says you never will be successful to get quiet, even for a little bit? 


Friday, August 25, 2023

Grocery Store Syndrome by Nancy L. Eady

The writing I do as an attorney creates problems for my fiction writing. The main difficulty, over-explaining things, is compounded by my years as a mathematics teacher at an underprivileged high school. If I wanted my 15- and 16-year-old general math students to hear my instructions, let alone follow them, I had to repeat them.  Many times.  

The combination of attorney and former mathematics teacher is deadly in fiction. I explain inferences most readers understand implicitly. I have to edit out “grocery store” syndrome. And I over-use dialog tags.

          “Hello,” Daphne said.

          “Hello,” John answered, “How are you today?”

          Daphne said, “I’m fine. How are you?”

          “I can’t complain,” John said.

(I’ll stop here to relieve those of you already gritting your teeth in frustration.)

What is “grocery store” syndrome? 

Sometimes, all the reader needs to know is that Jane bought bread on the way home. In my earliest drafts, however, Jane gets in the car, drives to the store, leaves the car, enters the store, goes down aisle one and up aisle two, reaches up to shelf five to select Wonder Bread (Jane not being on a health kick or gluten-free diet), goes to the cashier line, puts the bread on the conveyor belt, pays the cashier, watches the cashier put the bread in the bag, describes the cashier (whom the reader never sees again) in detail, picks up the bag, returns to the car, drives home, enters the house and then either puts the bread away or uses it to make a sandwich. By the time we do that, I’m exhausted, Jane’s exhausted, and those readers persistent enough to stick with me until the end are exhausted.


Have you found any pitfalls in your creative writing stemming from prior experiences?  How do you deal with them?

Monday, June 6, 2022

The Editor’s Thrill When a Book Comes Together

by Linda Rodriguez
(Linda is once again editing an anthology. After she wraps it up, she'll be back. But I thought it appropriate to give you her thoughts on editing an anthology since that's what's keeping her busy these days---E. B. Davis)

I’m co-editing an incredible anthology of Native poetry, The World Is One Place: Native American Poets Visit the Middle East. The National Endowment for the Arts is funding its publication. My co-editor is my former mentor and lifelong friend, Diane Glancy (who’s won all kinds of awards for her writing in all the categories—novel, short fiction, essay, memoir, poetry, playwriting, screenwriting—she’s even made a couple of movies!). Working with Diane alone would make me happy.

This anthology came about from a spark of an idea I had (when another of my favorite Native writers underwent a firestorm online for agreeing to honor her commitment to perform in Israel) that combined with a group of poems Diane had written about Syria from her own visits to the Middle East. We began to talk about finding other poets who had visited that part of the world and written about it. The publisher wrote the grant to the NEA, and it was accepted.

When we put out the call for contributors, we set no limits on what they could send. We simply asked for poems informed by their experience and views of the Middle East in any way they chose to look at it. We wondered if we might not receive an overabundance of political screeds, the Middle East being such a sore point with many, if not most, Native writers, who see what’s happening over there as almost déjà vu of what happened to our ancestors. Happily, we received a wide variety of superb poems that focused on the people, the land, the culture, the spiritual feelings their visits brought to the poets. The overarching theme seemed to be the commonalities the poets shared with their Middle Eastern hosts. We chose a line from one of the poems as the title to exemplify this—“The world is one place.”

This is not the first anthology I’ve edited. I knew, going in, the grind of trying to gather promised work and requested forms from poets—herding the proverbial cats would be simpler. And as we’re now in the stage of typesetting, we’re still waiting for a couple of work notes and a couple of permission forms. It is always thus. This book has taken a lot of work, but it will be such a special book. And we have a cover, a beautiful cover which uses Indigenous bead art made by one of our poets, an image of Petra. (I wish I could post it here for you all, but the contributors haven’t seen it yet.) As soon as those last two work notes arrive, we’ll send the manuscript out for blurbs and move into the production stage of the game with copyediting, proofreading, and more and more of the same to ensure quality. We’re already starting to plan the book launch.


I just went over the manuscript once again and had the great good fortune that comes once in a while with something you’ve worked hard on where you read it again and say to yourself, “This is really good!” This is the time all editors live for—when the book is coming together, when all the grunt work is paying off, when you can take a step back to find that all those stubborn pieces fit together into a thing of beauty. I’ve learned it’s important at such times to step back and savor the moment. Soon enough, there will be stubborn typos that sneak in somewhere new after you eradicate them, the struggle with the printer to capture the colors just right on the cover, and reviews awaited with the hope that the reviewer isn’t in a bad mood on the day s/he reads the book. Soon enough, there will be delays in shipping when we’re trying to get books across the country in time for a reading and Amazon reviews that complain that it’s “too political”/”not political enough.” For now, I’m stepping back and resting for a moment in quiet enjoyment of this lovely book we’ve all created. I think chocolate is definitely called for here.

Linda Rodriguez’s three novels featuring Cherokee campus police chief, Skeet Bannion—Every Hidden Fear, Every Broken Trust, and Every Last Secret—have received critical recognition and awards, such as Latina Book Club Best Book of 2014, St. Martin’s Press/Malice Domestic Best First Traditional Mystery Novel Award, selections of Las Comadres National Latino Book Club, 2nd Place in the International Latino Book Awards, finalist for the Premio Aztlán Award, 2014 ArtsKC Fund Inspiration Award, and Barnes & Noble mystery pick. Her short story, “The Good Neighbor,” published in the anthology, Kansas City Noir, has been optioned for film.

For her books of poetry, Skin Hunger and Heart’s Migration, Rodriguez received numerous awards and fellowships, including the Thorpe Menn Award for Literary Excellence, the Midwest Voices and Visions Award, the Elvira Cordero Cisneros Award, the 2011 ArtsKC Fund Inspiration Award, and Ragdale and Macondo fellowships. Rodriguez was 2015 chair of the AWP Indigenous/Aboriginal American Writer’s Caucus, past president of the Border Crimes chapter of Sisters in Crime, a founding board member of Latino Writers Collective and The Writers Place, and a member of International Thriller Writers, Wordcraft Circle of Native American Writers and Storytellers, and Kansas City Cherokee Community. Find her at http://lindarodriguezwrites.blogspot.com.

Monday, January 13, 2020

RIP Darlings!

By Shari Randall

Of all the writing rules out there – and there are a lot – the one every writer knows is “Kill your darlings.” Stephen King expanded on this advice from William Faulkner (at least he did according to Google) and said “Kill your darlings, kill your darlings, even when it breaks your egocentric little scribbler’s heart, kill your darlings.” 

Darlings. Those lines of dialogue, those descriptions, those witty one liners that we writers love, that make us proud. That make us think, “that’s a good one. That’s writing!” The chapter that makes us laugh, or shudder as we sit at the keyboard. The character we enjoy so much we’d like to take him out to lunch. 

The problem is, well, there could be lots of problems, and the biggest is my reluctance to hit the delete button on those darlings. Stephen King is right – killing my darlings does break my egocentric little scribbler’s heart. I find myself arguing with, well, myself about the fate of those darlings:

The dialogue doesn’t ring true to the characters. But it’s funny…
The description is too long. But it’s sheer poetry!
That chapter is so exciting. But it doesn’t further the plot…
That character is so much fun to write. Does the world really need another homicidal prom queen?

But, but… I love my darlings, especially some of my characters. So I’m going to bid them a fond farewell here before I hit DELETE.

A fond pat on the head to Spumoni, the loveable mutt from Fairweather Farm.  Scrappy and loyal, tail always wagging, Spumoni was a little too good for his own good. I needed a farm pet that would get into trouble. So bye-bye Spumoni and hello Hairy Houdini, an irascible miniature goat who never met a pen he couldn’t escape.

The police department of my tiny Connecticut town had too many named characters, so thank you and farewell Officer Moskovitz, enjoy your retirement in Florida.

Ah, Lu Fairweather, slender and dark, with a strip of gray highlighting your artistic brow (probably because I was reading that biography of Susan Sontag while I was writing you). Au revoir. I will miss your feminine mystique, your dangling Elsa Peretti earrings, your French press coffee and no filter cigarettes, your air of disdainful sophistication. 

Have you had to kill any darlings lately? Feel free to give them a shout out below.

Shari Randall is the author of the Lobster Shack Mysteries from St. Martin's Press. Her latest are Drawn and Buttered and The Queen of Christmas.



Sunday, August 27, 2017

Two Keys to Page-Turning Novels

Even Bears Sometimes Get Lost in the Woods
By James M. Jackson

Reviews of my Seamus McCree novels suggest many readers find them to be page-turners. Some even “complain” that they lost sleep because they couldn’t put the story down. I can sympathize. There are certain authors whose books I can’t put down—and it’s not necessarily because they are action thrillers.

I researched the issue and paid attention to how authors I can’t put down reel me in to reading just one more scene. “I’ll put the book down at the next white space,” I say, and two hours later I’m still reading. (White space is the term I use for a scene break or chapter break where there are a few blank lines separating the scenes (sometimes it includes a glyph) or—like with chapters—a new page where the next scene starts.)

I incorporated what I learned into Lesson 6 of my online course “Revision and Self-Editing.” Books that capture my attention and don’t let me go have two key components that books I can easily put down do not.

To keep me reading past the point I planned to stop requires a terrific “prompt” at the end of the scene. What makes a good prompt? There is no one way to do it, and if an author uses the same technique at the end of every scene, it could get as obnoxious as the cliffhangers of the 1914 serial Perils of Pauline flicks, where at every break the heroine is about to die.

The ending can be loaded with emotional punch, or a hint or premonition of change, or a question the reader wants answered. The scene can end with a line of dialogue that provides a twist or surprise. The POV character can make a promise (to another character or to herself) and we wonder whether she has really turned over a new leaf or what disaster will come from that decision. Whatever the actual content, it’s important to keep things open-ended. If there is no further suspense, there is no reason to keep reading. And if an author puts their POV character to bed and turns off the light, readers may decide to do the same. Zzzzzzzz.

An intriguing prompt is only half the battle. The terrific scene ending induces the reader to turn a page they didn’t intend to, but they aren’t yet committed to the next scene. That’s the job of that scene’s first few lines. They must set the hook to retain the reader while at the same time orienting him regarding who is in the scene (and who the Point-of-View character is), where and when it takes place, and what the first action is.

Lots of authors (including me in my early drafts) want to make sure readers understand the mechanics of the transition from one scene to the next. But, readers are smart. They know if the character was in California and plans to fly to New York, and the next time we see her she is in New York, she probably took the plane. Unless relevant conflict is involved, we don’t need to get her to the airport, through security and onto the plane, served tomato juice, deplane, grab a taxi, ring the doorbell, go through a long recitation of the last few days in California, etc., etc.

Let’s say we left our heroine worried about whether she was wise to dye her hair purple without letting her lover (who claims to adore her dirty blond hair) know. If the next scene opens with her lover throwing a fit about the dye job, the reader doesn’t care about the details of the trip. Or if the author wants a reaction scene to deepen reader connection with the character, she might cut directly to the heroine’s increasing anxiety as she self-talks her way through doing the laundry, waiting for her lover to get home.

Here’s another example to illustrate the point. Let’s say a scene ends with Barbara slamming out of her sister’s house (an action scene; her sister is named Molly). The next scene is set in a pub where Barbara meets her best friend, Trish, to kvetch (a reaction scene setting up the next action scene). Many authors would take the reader from the sister’s house to the bar: Barbara gets in the car, drives, parks, walks into the bar, her eyes have to adjust to the light, finally sees her friend in a back booth, smiles and waves and walks over, sits down and orders a beer.

I don’t know about you, but I start reading all that and think, “I don’t need to read this now,” and slip my bookmark in place (or close my Kindle).

But if the next scene began with dialogue like this (which assumes we’ve met Trish before), I could be kicking myself a half hour later because I still don’t want to put the book down.

“Next time,” Barbara said, “I’m going to rip her hair out and test her DNA.” She raised her mug high over her head to order another.

Trish’s hoot temporarily drowned out Lyle Lovett moaning from Lefty’s jukebox. “Oh, Molly’s your sister, all right. No one else can jerk your chain so bad. It ain’t even three o’clock and you’re already doin’ shooters with your beer.”

“You say so.” Barbara rolled her shoulders and a bit of tension released from her neck. Thank God she had called Trish. She had been in such a blind fury she didn’t even remember driving here. God, she hoped she hadn’t run that red light with the snitch camera like the last time she was pissed off at Molly. “Mama always said, ‘Don’t get mad. Get even.’ I owe her big, and I got a plan.”

“Oh Lordy,” Trish said. “What do I have to talk you out of this time?”

I’m sure the authors reading this blog could make this snippet stronger, but this example has accomplished a lot in a few lines. The author has defined the POV character (Barbara) and provided additional characterization.

We have a setting (Lefty’s — probably a bar, some place that plays Country music.)

There is a transition from the prior scene to this one as Barbara reflects on how she got here (and provided a speck of backstory about getting nailed for running a red light).

We know the scene objective (Barbara is trying to solicit Trish to carry out revenge).

We have evidence that Trish is going to resist Barbara and so we anticipate conflict between them.

Wouldn’t you want to know what the scheme is and whether Trish can talk her out of it. Of course, good authors make sure to vary their scene openings as well as their scene endings to keep them interesting and fresh.

Readers, does this jibe with your experiences, or is there something else that makes you read late into the night?

Authors, if you’re interested in learning more about Revisions and Self-Editing, the next month-long course starts October 1. You can find more information on my website at https://jamesmjackson.com/2017-course.html You’ll receive a discounted fee if you sign up before September 5.



Sunday, October 30, 2016

Two Current Editing Peeves

My current writing tasks include editing others’ novellas and rewriting some of my own work. If you are a published author, you may not want me reading your book while I am in this strongly focused editing mode, because I notice flaws (or at least what I consider flaws). Recently two have stuck out in books I have read.

Redundant Fluff in Writing

She shrugged her shoulders and … and I’ve stopped and mentally crossed out her shoulders. Have you tried shrugging a leg recently?

He nodded his head. Try nodding your knee a few times. How did that go?

She reached her hand. Now, I’ll grant one can reach a foot or a toe, or with a tongue, even with an elbow, but if it’s a hand we’re talking about, my sense is that the reader presumes the reaching is done by a hand unless you specify another body part.

Sometimes I trip over a flabby modifier that should either be eliminated or strengthened. For example, “There were about six thingamabobs.” Occasionally the story does revolve on there being about six of something, but most often six or a half-dozen suffices.


Order Counts – Telling does not equal foreshadowing

I’ve noticed several instances where the presentation order in exposition, or a combination of exposition and dialogue, is off. Often the sequence involves a tell coming before the show that illustrates the point. Consider this bit (totally made up):

Hannah was so mad she couldn’t talk. Steve slammed out of the car, closing the door so hard her ears ached from the bang and her sunglasses dropped from the overhead compartment. “Up yours,” he shouted. Grabbing for the sunglasses before they hit the gearshift, she knocked them under the seat. While retrieving them, she scratched the right lens beyond repair. Her fists tightened so hard in anger she snapped the earpiece. “You . . . you.” A vision of her dead mother appeared before her, and she couldn’t spit out the cussword she had intended.

Don’t you agree this would be stronger without the first sentence? I think as writers we stick in that first sentence to remind us where we are going. That’s fine for an early draft, but it should be excised before the final version. And did Steve utter his words after he had gotten out of the car and slammed the door? Or had he spoken those before or during his exit?

For public speeches, we are often advised to “tell them what you are going to say. Say it. Tell them what you just said.”

For fiction, we don’t need the introduction, and if the show is done well enough, the reader knows exactly what happened and how the character feels about it, so we don’t need the retelling, either.

An example of this problem starts with a summary sentence, say: Hannah was glad the day had gone so well, even though it had a miserable start.

The author then takes us through Hannah’s actions throughout the day, all in the past tense. Even well written, the bad stuff happening to Hannah lacks suspense because we already know she considered the day had gone well.

Okay – those are my two complaints for the day. What’s bugged you in recent reads that you wish the author or editor had fixed?


~ Jim

Sunday, August 2, 2015

Self-Editing (Just: Another Four-letter Word)

I am at an exciting point in my current WIP, Doubtful Relations. I have finished the final (?) rewrite, and am doing the last bit of polishing before shipping it off to a few beta readers to find out if it really is the final rewrite.

I have a whole lesson (#12) in my class on self-editing devoted to nits: those final things I need to check before I am willing to send a manuscript off to see the sights. One aspect of that nit-checking process is considering my overused words.

I have a list of words that cause me issues. I overuse them or I have discovered they are frequent indicators of sloppy or flabby writing. My list has grown over time. Some of the words on this list rarely still appear in my manuscripts—that’s self-editing at its best—I no longer need to fix that mistake because I don’t make it any more.

Here is my current list of problem words and why they are a problem:

■      About (Which I added to this list after I tested the word frequency of Ant Farm and found 372 in a 100,000-word manuscript)
■      After (Am I telling again? Best way to indicate sequence of events?)
■      All of (Is all sufficient? And is it really all?)
■      Almost (A flabby modifier)
■      Always (100% of the time always? If so, state the fact; if not, don’t use!)
■      Appear (It appears I overuse this when I mean seem; a rewrite can often eliminate both appear and seem.)
■      As (Make sure the simile adds to the story.)
■      As you know (Then why am I telling you?)
■      Entirely (Often unnecessary. She considered it entirely possible George could edit this sentence to advantage.)
■      Finally (See Start/Began. If needed, make sure it is the last thing in the sequence and appears at the end of the sentence/paragraph when you want the tension to drop.)
■      However (I often generate overly complicated sentences when this word is present.)
■      In the meantime (I’ll search for a better way to reference the passage of time.)
■      Just (Another four-letter word I just overuse entirely too much by including it as a filler.)
■      Middle of (I tend to place action in the middle of the room or road or country or century or…)
■      Nod (My conversational beats are littered with characters nodding at each other; left unchanged a reader might nod off.)
■      Of course (leading filler?)
■      Off of (Is off sufficient?)
■      Perhaps (Overused. Make sure this sentence justifies its use.)
■      Poor (Unless this refers to a monetary solution or used in dialog, change to a better adjective.)
■      Quite (Wishy-washy flab. See Very.)
■      Respective (Author intrusion may have occurred.)
■      Started/Began (Because I am thinking of the action sequence I can fall into the trap of STARTING the action, AND THEN continuing the action and FINALLY concluding the action. Time to remember the Nike commercial and JUST DO IT (which I will modify to DO IT <grin>).
■      Stood (I discovered this one time while looking at “too.” I often use it as an unnecessary stage direction.)
■      Successive (Better to lay out the sequence rather than talk about it?)
■      Suddenly (Make it so by action or reaction; this is often a tell.)
■      That (Is that that filler or is that necessary for understanding?)
■      Then/and Then (see Started/Began)
■      Too (When used as a too frequent tag I overuse at the end of sentences.)
■      Took (I also discovered this one while looking for “too.” I use it as a catchall and some should be changed to more descriptive words.)
■      There is/There are (Weak opening to a sentence)
■      Turn (Unnecessary stage direction?)
■      Very (Undistinguished flab. See Quite.)
■      When (Is this the best way to reflect synchronous events?)

It takes me eight to ten hours to go through an entire manuscript to consider each use and then eliminate or modifier the language as necessary.

Do you have “favorite” words you overuse?

~ Jim

Sunday, May 10, 2015

Copyedits

I recently read an interesting discussion on a listserv about self-published authors and whether they do (or should) use copyeditors. I am in the middle of proofreading Ant Farm after completing my review of the Kindle Press copyedits. What I discovered may help inform that conversation.

As readers of this blog may recall, my initial plan was to self-publish Ant Farm. Instead I decided to enter the book into the new Kindle Scout program. After the 30-day nomination period, Kindle Press selected it for publication. Although not required under our contract, they chose to give it a thorough copyediting.

I was fine with that; the more eyes on the manuscript, the more likely nothing would slip through. I didn’t expect the new editor to catch much. I had already paid for an edit of an earlier version of the book, and I had had a number of subsequent beta readers. Plus, both Jan (my better half) and I had carefully proofread Ant Farm before I submitted it to the Kindle Scout program.

Once I received the copyedits, it did not take me long to determine I was wrong on several counts. On the ninth line of the manuscript, the editor found an errant homonym that all previous readers had blasted right through. In addition to several homonym issues, the Kindle Press editor caught more than one factual error that I would have sworn I had checked and rechecked, and she noted a number of story questions. Nothing was major; I could resolve most of the questions with a line or two of text added or subtracted or moved around.

She also added a gallon’s worth of commas to match the Kindle Press style and hyphenated a ton of words that my dictionary had smushed together into single words. That’s a price I pay for switching publishers, each of whom has their own stylesheet.

The edit did not kick up any major issues, but the sum total of changes is a much-improved book.

So why wouldn’t every self-published author want a strong copyedit? It comes down to money and time. I do not know what Kindle Press paid the copyeditor, but based on the number of edits and comments, it took her quite a bit of time, and was probably not inexpensive. The process took many calendar days. Kindle Press accepted my book on March 2. I received the edits on April 29.

Based on the listserv discussion, it seems many self-published authors do not think the copy editing process is worth the cost. They also worry about lost sales during the two and a half months delay between when they have a “finished” manuscript and when the editing process is completed.

Each author has to perform their own cost/benefit analysis. After this experience, I will always choose to have professionals help me make my manuscript as strong as it can be before I release it to the world. It has to do with my pride of authorship. It also has to do with the kind of reader I am. Finding too many copyedits or factual errors can ruin the story for me. If they come early in my reading, I’ll put the book down and pick up something else.

Am I an old fuddy-duddy on this issue, or is the tide turning against books with poor editing?

~ Jim

Sunday, May 3, 2015

A bunch of writers walk into a room…


By the time this blog goes live, I will be headed back from the Oklahoma Writers’ Federation Inc. Conference in Oklahoma City. I’m on the faculty for the conference and speaking in three sessions—on self-editing, dialogue and creating atmosphere (they had way cooler titles than this, just sayin’).

Obviously, as I write this, I have no idea how it went—if my PowerPoint worked, if I ended up with an impossible question, if I passed out in front of a room full of people.

You know, the usual.

Like most writers, I prefer to hide behind the printed word, not actually say anything out loud. 

Especially to a bunch of my peers. But, I’m getting better. And mostly, I want to brave my nerves just for the fact that if any of the information I have to share helps another writer, it will be worth it.

What’s the most useful piece of information you’ve picked up at a conference, workshop or writers’ meeting?

Sunday, August 3, 2014

A Writers’ Retreat of a Sort


Starting today I have a rare opportunity for the modern writer: a whole week alone.

I have to tell you, this never happens. I’m married. I have a five-year-old. I am never, ever alone. Which is great, because I absolutely love my family and couldn’t imagine not having them around. But, like most people, I’m much more productive creatively when I’m flying solo with no distraction.

Which rarely happens. And when it does, it happens in little chunks here and there—just enough that I’m able to write and edit and hear myself think. But a whole week? Never. Ever.

How’d this come to be? Well, basically, I’m missing out on my favorite time of the whole year. Each summer, my family heads to Colorado with my parents and we spend a week hiking, eating and relaxing in the shadow of Longs Peak. It’s a great time, marked by cool mornings, sweaty jaunts up mountains (see above—the hubby and me on top of Twin Sisters last summer) and lots of reading on a wide porch.

And this year, I won’t be going.

I’m due to have a baby in September, and, after talking to my doctor, decided that suddenly spending a week at 8,000 feet might not be the best idea. I did go on the trip when I was pregnant with my son, but I’ll be nearly three months further along than I was then.

Because he’s awesome, my husband offered to take our son anyway—a great gesture and one that the kiddo will most definitely appreciate. He loves Colorado and he loves grandparent time—so win-win for the little man. I’m sure my husband won’t mind the fresh air either (again, see the above pic as proof), even while on single-parent duty.

While I’d much rather be curled up with some tea and a book in the shadow of Longs Peak, I’m trying to make the most of this very rare week alone.

When I’m not physically at my day job, I plan to be writing or editing—two things I don’t normally have much time to do in the evenings during the week. Obviously, I’m hoping this will mean getting tons of work done. Not only because that would be fantastic, but also because I may never get an opportunity with so much alone time again. Or at least for a very long time.

What would you do with a writer-ly week alone?

Sunday, July 20, 2014

Word Crimes and Blurred Lines


My Twitter feed blew up Tuesday with a bit of pop culture genius from none other than Weird Al Yankovic.

Maybe you’ve seen it, or maybe you haven’t, but Weird Al released a parody of Robin Thicke’s “Blurred Lines” made specifically for grammar nerds called “Word Crimes.” And, because Blogger seems to hate video embeds, here’s the link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8Gv0H-vPoDc

Basically, the video highlights, in a very funny way, some of the writing world’s favorite grammar lightening rods, including: apostrophes in words that aren’t possessive, “could care less” (we all know it should be couldn’t, right?), and the good, ol’ Oxford comma.

As someone with a long editorial background (first newspapers, and now freelance), I, of course, watched the video and geeked out just like everyone else. But I also caught myself hoping there’d be a sequel that included some of the mistakes I see time and time again while editing, beta reading, and critiquing.

There are many I can think of, but my top three are below (though I have no idea how to put them to music):

1. Hyphenating modifiers that already have an “-ly” suffix. This one is wrong ALL THE TIME. If a modifer ends in “-ly,” you do NOT hyphenate it with the word after it. So, there should be no “carefully-placed flowers” or “fortunately-timed appearance.” None of that. Drop the hyphen.

2. Using “due to” and “prior to.” This one has firmly driven me nuts since my high school journalism days. When writers use “due to” or “prior to,” they mostly seem to do so because those phrases sound more high brow than, say, “because of “ or “before.” But those phrases are incorrect and plain, old “because of” and “before” are what you should be using.

Both due and prior modify words. Do not attach a “to” to them and hope you sound smarter. You don’t. It’s just like those people you silently correct in your head who use “I” instead of “me” because they’re trying to sound smarter. When you use these two phrases, you’re acting in the very same way.

3. Forego and forgo: Learn the difference. Forego is to go before. Forgo is to go without. They are not interchangeable. The one with an “e” isn’t the Old English spelling. If you swap one for the other, you’re doing it wrong.

The same goes for further/farther and assure/ensure/insure. Learn them. Use them correctly.

What are some of your grammar pet peeves?

Sunday, June 22, 2014

Speed Dating Your Own Manuscript


I’ve blogged about my crazy writing schedule many times. Balancing being a mom, having a full-time job, tons of freelance, and writing my crime fiction—it’s not easy, but, boy, is it worth it when I actually get to write.

Revision is the same way for me. I tend to revise quite a bit as I go, mostly because I find it so much easier if I get it all out right the first time. Yes, I know this is a bit unusual—I have many writing buddies who feel like if you go back during a first draft, you’re dead in the water. They much prefer to get it all out on paper and then spend time combing through it once the base is there. But that’s never really been me.

All that said, my most recent manuscript has required more heavy, after-the-fact revision than I’ve ever felt was necessary before. I revised as I wrote, just like usual, but the nature of this manuscript (dual first-person narratives) and the real “plottiness” of the story meant it has needed much, much more time in revision than anything I can remember working on, aside from my very first stab at a book. And we all know how those first manuscripts go—they’re a writing lesson wrapped in a marathon, to be sure.

To go with the unusual nature of this manuscript’s behavior, I decided to try a little something different once I thought I might be FINALLY done revising it.

Spend a day with it.

I hadn’t gotten a chance to read the thing in a short time period. Rather, because of all my other commitments, it would normally take me two weeks or more to read the full 467 pages. (Yeah, it’s super long).

And with that long a period between when I started and when I finished a read, I felt I might be missing something.

I couldn’t tell if I had the emotional ebb and flow right. Had I parsed out enough of the backstory? Did a running joke actually run through the whole thing or did it only show up when it darn well felt like it?

So, as a very, very rare luxury to myself, I took an entire day off work, just to read. Maybe a silly use of vacation time, but I felt it was important to see this one as a whole.

And you know what? I learned more about this manuscript in that day than I probably had in months of here-and-there revision. Spending that many uninterrupted hours with it meant I could see the little things that worked, the things that didn’t, and what could get slashed out all together.

I also figured out that despite the necessary changes, the manuscript was in way better shape than I thought. Thus: I feel super relieved.

I also have a few days of inputting my notes (I read it on paper rather than on a screen—another glorious change, no offense to my MacBook or Kindle), but in the scheme of things, that day really saved me plenty of time and frustration.

Do you ever take a large chunk of time to read your writing in revision or another part of the process? Does it help you?

Thursday, September 26, 2013

THE LAST EDIT



My daughter, Mary, at Filoli gardens.
Sometime last winter, I finished the third book in my Catherine Jewell mystery series, Ladies of the Garden Club, and put it aside and out of my mind for the time being. Instead I concentrated on getting the second book, Daylilies for Emily’s Garden published before Malice Domestic as well as my middle-grade book, The Sherlock Holmes Detective Club I had finished long ago, but needed attention to reformatting and a final read through.

Spring and summer are always a busy time for me. There’s the Malice Domestic Convention in May, vacations and various events like graduation open houses, picnics, wedding showers, and more get-togethers  with family and friends that come up when the weather is nice. For some reason this year has had more birthday parties for all the little ones now in my extended family. Of course, for me there’s the lawn and garden work that gets overwhelming from March through October. There’s not only the mowing – and not with a riding mower – but planting, weeding and trips to garden centers to buy more plants. Then comes strawberry season, and this year my patch had more than enough to supply my love of strawberries. Later the lettuce and peas were ready to be picked followed by cucumbers, beans and blueberries. This year, however, because of one of the rainiest summers I’ve ever had, the tomatoes, peppers and other vegetables suffered so I had little freezing to do and no canning  My sister living less than fifty miles south of me suffered from lack of rain, yet still had a bountiful crop.  Of course, my grass and weeds, if not my veggies, thrived like never before.

Maggie by my blueberry patch 
So any writing or writing related activities I’ve done this past spring and summer has been limited to my weekly blogs, the occasional poem, mostly started and not finished, and three short stories, plus a book signing for my second book at a local bookstore - poor neglected second child.  I did have it in time for the Malice Domestic at least.

Finally, after much nagging from those who have read and enjoyed the first two books in The Catherine Jewell Mystery Series, I started my final edit of Ladies of the Garden Club toward the end of August and finished my read through making corrections and changes. Now I’m sending it three to five chapters at a time to my Guppy critique partners. I’ve also given a hard copy to a writer in my local writing group, who has been my beta reader for my other books, and I respect her opinion, and I’m sending chapters by email attachments to my sister, who is now retired from teaching. And for all those who think family can’t be trusted to be critical enough, this sister is a very critical reader. Many, but not all of the mysteries I liked and shared with her, she found faults with the writing, and her comments were astute.

One of the things surprising me in going back to this book after so much time away from it was sometimes reading scenes or even once a chapter, that I didn’t remember writing. The same is true with my critique partners, Ann and Mary. Their comments are often “I don’t remember reading this. Is it new?” And I can’t remember if it’s a revision or an addition from their first reading and editing of this book. And just like me as I reread these chapters I’d stored in the closet in my mind for so long, they’re enjoying reading it again. They know the villain, how it ends, but they’re enjoying meeting the characters again and getting reacquainted with them. They’re also chuckling at the humorous spots again. And they’re finding the little glitches – the missed quotations marks, etc.


For me the most stressful time of writing is here. Soon I’ll have all my edits received and will do that last and final edit. My granddaughter, the graphic artist who has designed all my covers, is working on this cover now. I can’t wait to see what she comes up with.  Hopefully, I’ll have this latest book up and out in the next month or so, and I’ll finally have copies of the Ladies of the Garden Club in my hand. Then I’ll be able to start scheduling book signings for this book and my others, too, including the anthologies I’m in.

So why is it so stressful for me? It’s because I want this book to be perfect. I know it’s not a book that will appeal to everyone. No book is, but at least I want those who have read and enjoyed my other books to enjoy this one, too. And I want it to be totally glitch free.

What stage of your writing is the most stressful for you?

If you’re not a writer, what do you find most stressful?