I found the answer to a question that popped up several years
ago. The basic argument was this: If male authors outsell women authors, then
women authors should mask their sex and write like men. In the virtual world
it’s easy to mask sex by choosing an androgynous or male pseudonym (which
several female authors have done), posting no pictures or posting a picture of
a male. In light of what I’ve discovered, posing as a male may not be useful.
There is more than physical factors that define the difference between male and
female authors. Men write differently than women. But how does men’s writing
vary from women’s writing? What distinguishes it?
Intuitively, I thought
of content. Very few men write romance, but then Nicolas Sparks has enjoyed
success in that genre. In the mystery genre, Agatha Christie became as much an
icon as Sir Arthur Cannon Doyle. My intuition failed me. Content wasn’t
necessarily a factor—and yet it was a factor, but in a way I didn’t understand.
At about the same time, I read a blog (I forget which blog and
who wrote the blog—my apologies to that blogger.) recommending a book, The Secret Life Of Pronouns, What Our Words
Say About Us. Had I time to read the book during this period, I would have
put two and two together and realized that the question and the book went hand
in hand. I recently read the book and now understand what the author James W.
Pennebaker’s research contributed to the argument.
Dr. Pennebaker, a social psychologist, studies language to
find out what our use of words says about us. Through many experimental trials,
recording thousands of conversations and analyzing written works, Pennebaker
determined that men and women speak differently. Our sentences are composed of
nouns, verbs, modifiers, pronouns, articles, prepositions, etc. He categorized some
words as Content Words: nouns, regular and action verbs and most modifiers.
Everything else he categorized as Function/Style Words. We hear mainly Content
Words, and yet when people talk to each other they use more Function/Style
Words. How we use Function/Style Words can say a great deal about us from our
socio-economic status to our emotional states.
Here are some of his conclusions: (Pennebaker Kindle 792)
·
Women use first-person singular pronouns more
than men
·
Men and women use first-person plural words at
the same rate
·
Men use articles more than do women
·
There are no differences in the use of positive
emotion words
·
Women use more cognitive (understand, know,
think or because reason, rationale) words than men (He also points out that
Aristotle would be astonished since he thought women were less rational than
men.)
·
Women use social words (words referring to
society—people, family, they, parents, etc.) at far higher rates than men
·
Men use more “big” words, nouns, prepositions,
numbers, more words per sentence and swear words
·
Women use more pronouns, verbs, negative emotion
words, negations, certainty words (always, absolutely) and hedge phrases (I
think, I believe).
Hedge phrases, Pennebaker points out aren’t necessarily
negative. They reveal that women are more aware that their opinion is but one
of many, whereas men are less aware of others’ opinions.
Here are some of the more generalized conclusions based on
Pennebaker’s findings.
·
Young people speak more like women than men
·
At some point after twenty years of age, men and
women’s speech diverges
·
As men and women age, that divergence
diminishes. One would think that hormones could account for this diverge and
converge, but his tests, which he admits are too narrow to make conclusions
from, do not support the hormone theory.
In one chapter of the book, one that fascinated me,
Pennebaker compares and analyzes several screenplay writers’ dialogue for male
and female characteristics. Prototypical male representing 1 on the scale, and
prototypical female as 9. I won’t present his findings, but it is clear that
some writers overcompensate in male/female characterization. But, Pennebaker
warns, if writers present their characters as too prototypical they may seem like
cardboard characters. Pennebaker also analyzes politicians like Abraham Lincoln
and John Kerry, discussions that explain election results.
His research also revealed that:
·
Until age twelve people have a positive
self-image
·
From 13-20 people experience the lowest
self-image in their lives
·
From 20 on, self-image gradually rises, so much
so that 65 year olds and 9 year olds enjoy the same positive self-image
·
After 70, self-image declines.
Dr. Pennebaker’s observations and revealing facts were
almost too numerous for me to assimilate as I put his information into my
writing. I recommend all writers read this book because it is invaluable for characterization.
Our dialogue reveals who the speakers are, their traits, emotional states, sex,
education, etc. Pennebaker makes clear that how we speak and write is more
important that what we say.
Several online gender tests are available online to test
your writing. (Here’s one:
http://www.hackerfactor.com/GenderGuesser.php)
Cut and paste sections from your manuscript into the test area to determine
what gender you are writing. Some sections of my writing tested as male, some female,
but most of the time, the analysis resulted in mixed results. It couldn’t
determine my sex. In the mystery genre, I’m glad for that result. From
Pennebaker’s findings, I conclude that I can change my writing so that it is
more characteristically male, but as I age this will occur naturally—so perhaps
will my chance for greater sales. It’s all up from here.