“…it turns out that
tripping over bodies and being electrocuted, accused of murder,
and flickered at by
ghosts makes me jumpy and irritable.”
Molly MacRae, Come
Shell or High Water, Kindle Loc. 1575
When widowed folklorist Maureen Nash
visits a legendary North Carolina barrier island shell shop, she discovers its
resident ghost pirate and the mystery of a local’s untimely death . . .
As a professional storyteller, Maureen Nash can’t help but see the narrative
cues woven through her life. Like the series of letters addressed to her late
husband from a stranger—the proprietor of The Moon Shell, a shop on Ocracoke
Island, off the coast of North Carolina. The store is famous with shell
collectors, but it’s the cryptic letters from Allen Withrow, the shop’s owner,
that convince Maureen to travel to the small coastal town in the middle of
hurricane season. At the very least, she expects she’ll get a good story out of
the experience, never anticipating it could end up a murder mystery . . .
In Maureen’s first hours on the storm-lashed island, she averts several
life-threatening accidents, stumbles over the body of a controversial Ocracoke
local, and meets the ghost of an eighteenth-century Welsh pirate, Emrys Lloyd.
To the untrained eye, all these unusual occurrences would seem to be random
misfortunes, but Maureen senses there may be something connecting these
stories. With Emrys’s supernatural assistance, and the support of a few new
friends, Maureen sets out to unravel the truth, find a killer, and hopefully
give this tale a satisfying ending . . . while also rewriting her own.
Amazon.com
Come Shell or High Water is the first book in
WWKs Molly MacRae’s Haunted Shell Shop mystery series. This book is close to my
heart. It is set on Ocracoke Island, one island south, in the Outer Banks chain
of barrier islands of North Carolina, of my home island of Hatteras. Be prepared
for some “shell” puns and jokes in this novel, like “like a bat out of shell”
or “annoying as shell.”
At the start of the book, Ocracoke is
just post-hurricane. Visitors have been banished from the island until services
and business owners can recover from storm damage. This is a realistic scenario
and routinely done by the authorities in times of storms. But it isn’t only
hurricanes that can strike Ocracoke. Right now, Route 12, the only road through
Ocracoke (which must be accessed at the north/south ends by ferry) is closed
due to a nor’easter causing ocean overwash—which means the ocean has breached
the road rendering it unnavigated by automobile. Weather happens here.
Main character, Maureen Nash, is a
likeable middle-aged widow with two grown sons. She’s normal except for talking
to her dead husband and seeing pirate ghosts.
Please welcome Molly to the flip-side
of WWK. E. B. Davis
What is Maureen’s connection to
Ocracoke?
She and her
husband first visited Ocracoke on their honeymoon and fell in love with it. When
they had children, they started taking them to the island each summer for
vacation.
Maureen is only in her
50s. Why is she retired already?
You could say
she’s retired from the research and fieldwork jobs she’s had as a malacologist
(see next
question to find out what a malacologist is), but only because those
jobs, like some of the rare freshwater mussels she studies, are hard to find
where she lives in northeast Tennessee. She isn’t really retired, though. She
works part time in the children's department of the public library. She’s also
a professional storyteller and has had some success getting picture book
retellings of folktales involving shells published.
What is a malacologist? And how many
are there in the US, like three?
Ha! You made me
laugh. A malacologist is a type of wildlife biologist who studies mollusks—animals
like squids, octopuses, snails. slugs, clams, and mussels. How many malacologists are there in the US? According
to a 2020 report from the US Bureau of Labor Statistics there are a whopping
19,300 and employment growth in the profession is predicted. How cool is that? A
scientist who studies only the shells, and not the animals that make them, is a
conchologist.
Are there fables about shells?
There are
folktales about shells, and the creatures that make them, from all over the
world. “The Boy and the Snails” is an Aesop’s fable (not snail-friendly at
all). There’s a lot of symbolism associated with shells, too, going back
thousands and thousands of years. They’ve been incorporated in ceremonies and
rituals worldwide. Burying shells in graves is a tradition in many cultures and
dates back to at least the Middle Stone Age in Africa. (Francesco d'Errico,
Lucinda Backwell, “Earliest evidence of personal ornaments associated with
burial: The Conus shells from Border Cave” Journal of Human Evolution, Volume
93, 2016, Pages 91-108, ISSN 0047-2484, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jhevol.2016.01.002.)
What is Maureen’s greatest fear?
Sharks.
Maureen hitches a sketchy entry onto
Ocracoke. Why is it “illegal,” and who enables her?
It might not technically
be illegal, but the immediate aftermath of a hurricane is no time for tourists
to be traipsing around a small, fragile island. There can be a massive amount
of clean up plus the need to repair and rebuild. Roads might be impassable.
Power might be out for days or weeks and fresh water and food in short supply. The
authorities rightly restrict access so the residents can get back on their feet
or return if they evacuated.
In Maureen’s
case, the person in Ocracoke from whom she’s renting told her she can still
have the place if she can get to the island. The ferry isn’t running, but an
old friend of Maureen’s is a ranger in the US Park Service. The friend is
boating over to Ocracoke to check the condition of the national park campground.
She agrees to take Maureen along, as an unauthorized favor, provided Maureen doesn’t
tell anyone.
During her ride to Ocracoke, she
acknowledges that she isn’t really drowning, but is half-drown by her own
assumptions. What is she referring to? How does she make them work for her?
She’s referring
to her assumptions that she can walk the deserted, post-hurricane beaches
without getting into trouble and that her other reason for going there—to snoop
around and find out why shell shop owner Allen Withrow has been sending her
late husband intriguing but scammy-sounding letters—isn’t totally mad.
Why does Maureen take a walk on the
beach?
She’s taking
biologist E.O. Wilson’s advice about spending time in nature to get her head
right, and to see what shells or other interesting things the hurricane washed
ashore.
Without knowing how she arrived,
Maureen wakes up inside a shop near town with amnesia after suffering an
electrical shock. Who finds her and what is their connection to the shop?
Glady and Burt
Weaver, octogenarian and septuagenarian sister and brother, find her. They live
across the street from the shop.
The shop is called The Moon Shell.
What is a moon shell?
The shop’s
original owner (Allen Withrow’s mother) named the shop after a large Clench’s
helmet shell, carved with a moonlit ocean scene, that she owned. But in the
real world, Naticidae, with the common name moon snail, is a family of predatory
sea snails. Their shells are called moon shells.
Why doesn’t Maureen like texting?
She knows it’s
irrational, but she doesn’t like to text with her sons because the last time
she heard from her husband was in a text asking, “1:00 lunch at the café?” But
he was gone before 1:00, killed in an electrical accident. She doesn’t go to
the café anymore, either.
Is Glady glib or truthful when she
says she can solve the murder better than law enforcement because she has a
long running mystery series?
That’s just so
hard to say, isn’t it? If you ask Glady, I’m sure she’ll say it’s the truth.
Other people’s assumptions actually help hide Maureen’s reason for being
on the island. Why do they think she’s there? When it comes down to it, after
the fact, it’s convoluted but not inaccurate, sort of.
Glady and Burt
have heard Allen say he’s expecting someone. They’ve also long thought he needs
help in the shop (he’s in his eighties). They assume the person he’s expecting
is someone he’s hired. They find Maureen in the shop and make another
assumption—Allen hired her, and she’s expected.
Who is Emrys Lloyd? Why can Maureen
see him while others can’t or at least what’s her first theory is soon after
she comes to from being shocked? Why is he an Accidental Pirate?
Emrys is a ghost.
He’s also a pirate. He says he didn’t intend to be a pirate, he didn’t want to
be a pirate, and he only did it once. Sadly, that one time didn’t work out well
for him. That was in 1750.
When Maureen regains
consciousness in the Moon Shell, Glady and Burt tell her they saw a flash in
the shop from their house. They went to investigate and found her and a table
lamp on the floor. None of them is sure what happened, but they assume she turned
on the lamp, it shorted and shocked her, and she fell, hit her head, and
knocked herself out. The problem is, now Maureen sees and hears someone else in
the shop that Glady and Burt don’t. She thinks she must be addled as a result
of what happened.
Why doesn’t Glady want Maureen to go
to see the doctor after her electrical shock?
Maureen would love to know the answer to that question,
too. When Maureen tells Glady that she really thinks she should call the
doctor, Glady says, “Mm, no. You really shouldn’t.”
Prior to building high on pilings,
buildings suffered routine flood damage. What did the islanders do to prevent
floating houses and to mitigate flood damage/mold?
Until
the hurricane of 1899 islanders apparently scuttled their floors by chopping a
hole with an axe. A drastic move? Yes, but better to let the house flood than
have it washed off its foundation. Soon after that hurricane, the Thomas family
built the first house in Ocracoke with a trapdoor in the floor specifically meant
for letting in flood waters. You can read a wonderful account of scuttling a
floor during the 1899 hurricane at the Ocracoke
Island Journal. The story involves a duck.
I was dismayed that Maureen’s old
friend, Patricia, sort of turns on her. Why would she do that without Maureen’s
provocation?
Maureen was dismayed, too, but Patricia thought Maureen
had gone back on her promise to keep quiet about her unauthorized lift to the
island.
What are Emrys’s patterns or loops?
There are stories of ghosts that endlessly repeat the
same motions. Emrys gives the example of a gray lady who walks a corridor over
and over, never varying. Maureen says that sounds like being caught in a film
loop. Emrys’s pattern, his loop, is based on the carved moon shell. He says
that, when he’s caught in his loop, “My entire focus is on the shell, with no
conscious awareness of anything else. As though the shell is my lifeline, my
source of breath and heartbeat.”
Why doesn’t Emrys like children?
He blames it on their high little voices. He and his
wife didn’t have children before he died. I bet, if he’d had children of his
own, he would have been a good father and head over heels in love with them.
The victim, Allen, owned The Moon
Shell. Who is he to Maureen? Who is he to Glady?
He’s no relation to either. Maureen goes to Ocracoke to
find out who Allen is to her late husband. He and Glady knew each other most of
their lives.
You have a good grasp of Ocracoke and
life on Ocracoke. Where did you get your experience/knowledge?
My husband and I started visiting in 1979, and we took
our children to the island for many years. We haven’t gotten there often in the
past 30 years, though. To try to make up for that, I subscribe to the community
newspaper and read “Ocracoke Newsletter” and “Ocracoke Island Journal,” two
online resources from a wonderful island shop called Village Craftsman. I’ve
also read a number of books about life on the island. There’s a bibliography of
those books in Come Shell or High Water. I also had the good fortune to correspond
with a woman who taught school in Ocracoke.
What’s next for Maureen? Since I don’t
think there were any murders on Ocracoke since the 19th century, can
we predict that the murder rate will accelerate wildly?
In book two, There’ll Be Shell to Pay, the body
of an unidentified woman is found in a tidal inlet, Emrys is missing, and a trio
of tourists calling themselves the Fig Ladies are playing detective. I feel
pretty bad about bringing murder to the island (over and over), luckily Maureen
is there to clean it all up. That book comes out in June 2025.
Here are some of the vocabulary words
I learned reading this book!
Susurrus—whispering, murmuring or rustling (often by water).
Apocryphal—of doubtful authenticity, although widely circulated as being true.
Paramnesia—a condition involving distorted memory or confusions of fact and
fantasy, such as confabulation or déjà vu. Surprise—doesn’t have anything to do
with Italian cheese!