Thank you, Writers
Who Kill, for inviting me to your blog. Writers who kill? That’s me.
Don’t call the FBI or, in my case, the RCMP. I’m a Canuck. All right. Now, why
do we do it, why do we kill people? The reasons are personal, of course, and
individual. Fear not, I’m not going to delve into the DSM (Diagnostic and
Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders). You don’t want to look inside my mind.
Just ask my wife. So, forget about me.
Let’s look at
things from the reader’s side of the knife. That’s what really matters: why
readers read, not why authors write. I’m not referring to sales and book
marketing mantras – find your tribe, expand your SM footprint, etc - although
the marketing gurus say everything hinges on sales. A lot does, I’ll admit.
However, more universally, everything hinges on readers, including those who
borrow from libraries or share your work twenty times.
Why
do readers read writers who kill? Why do so many people read crime/mystery
fiction? Why do so many watch crime/mystery creations? Think contemporary
cozies, historical ones, true crime, CSI spinoffs, law and order procedurals,
etc. I’m not complaining. It’s great. We crime writers have a large audience.
I’d say the number of crime/mystery novels published annually is second only to
that of romance novels.
Why
are crime/mystery stories such a big part of our current cultural milieu?
People must get something out of the genre.
Of
course, there’s the voyeur element. “Look, he's bloodier than buffalo guts.”
“Hey, her head’s half there. That incision looks like shark teeth.”
Secondly,
crime fiction can transport the reader to another world. A good author pushes
readers’ boundaries, nudging them toward an existence far removed from their
own.
Thirdly,
crime fiction can have a social or even ethical underpinning. Personally, I
like to embed – very deeply, I don’t preach to readers – an ethical conundrum
in my stories. In my first novel, Bay of Blood, a world-renowned
painter is not murdered because of envy or money – the usual tropes – but
because of past failings, shall we say. In my current work-in-progress, the
main murderee is killed because of his renunciation of money, his anti-greed.
My novels are police procedurals. They deliver detective work, forensic skill,
and plenty of dead ends and red herrings. The reader rides a wave of doubt as
they try to identify the perps. That’s what crime readers want: a challenging
ride, an intricate yet plausible mind teaser. Yet, at the same time, they can
find a deeply buried ethical message. For me, all novels - even whodunits -
should have an existential core.
I’m
not a psychologist or mind reader. However, I’m going to take a stab at
answering why people find murder mysteries so fascinating. Violent unexpected
death is horrendous. People cannot or do not want to face it directly. One way
of handling murder, one way of coming to terms with the worst of all human
crimes, is to watch someone solve it. “Look, they caught the bastard.”
Perhaps
crime fiction is soothing. It conquers evil, and somehow puts the world in a
positive light. Good guys win, bad guys go to jail. On the flip side, I could
be barking up the wrong tree. Maybe people just want blood and guts.
***
A.M.
Potter writes detective fiction, which he calls North Noir, aka Canuck Noir.
You know what he says? “Leave your Scandinavian Noir in the sauna. It’s time
for North Noir.” On the bio side, he grew up in Nova Scotia and Boston. He's
traveled the world, working dozens of jobs. Like any good detective, he knows
both sides of the thin blue line. He's used numerous aliases (for non-nefarious
purposes, of course). You’ll have to take his word on that.
Author of the
Detective Eva Naslund Series | First book: Bay
of Blood, Black Opal Books, March 2019
Good luck with your debut novel.
ReplyDeleteI am confused a bit by how a police procedural can be "noir" - perhaps you could expand on that?
congratulations on your debut! I read (and write) mysteries for the puzzle-solving aspect, which usually includes a body.
ReplyDeleteInteresting post, A.M. I read traditional mysteries because I enjoy following an amateur sleuth trying to solve the puzzle of who did it. Good luck with your writing.
ReplyDeleteThanks for visiting, A.M. Interesting post. I read and write murder mysteries because I like following the twists and turns and then to see it all come right in the end - unlike the real world.
ReplyDeleteBest of luck and congratulations on your debut.
Congratulations on your debut novel. Like Margaret I read and write mysteries for the puzzle solving aspect.
ReplyDeleteHi Jim. Sorry about my tardy reply. I was on the road. Right, it's confusing. According to one definition of crime noir, the protagonist can't be a cop, but has to be an amateur sleuth. I play with a different definition of noir, one that considers it to be tone or background. The narrative thrust of my books is police work and the main characters are police detectives, so I think of the books as police procedurals. However, I try to layer in hard-boiled noir elements like cynical characters. In the end, though, I aim for a police procedural. I want cops to solve a whodunit.
ReplyDelete