A writer friend of mine unexpectedly died this month. Her Celebration of Life was well organized and very well attended. While listening to the many heartfelt songs, poems, and tributes, I was overwhelmed by the volume of non-writerly activities she had supported in her daily hours.
She was a driving and volcanic force behind a spiraling
galaxy of vital community, social and political activism, and grant-writing and
fund-raising efforts. She was a professional mediator who helped troubled teens.
She was a powerful advocate for women and families in need. Her friendships
were true blue, deeply felt, long-standing, all-encompassing, and diverse. She
took advantage of every opportunity to travel to distant shores and exotic
lands. She founded the first writer’s group I joined, ushering newbie me into a
community of creative fiction writers that sustains me to this day.
I left her celebration dazed, wondering where I had
parked my car and thinking: “Holy heck, when did she sleep?” Sliding into my
car, I reviewed my life feeling like a slacker until it dawned on me that she
had never completed the manuscript of her debut novel. Now we will never know what
could have been written. Death has taken her pen.
This end result raised a few questions in my mind: Gabriel
Garcia Marquez told his sons to destroy his final unfinished novel. The
manuscript was too rambling; it had too many pieces; it was too scattered. He
had run out of creative editing lifetime. Despite his direction, his sons are
readying it for publication. What are your thoughts on this posthumous
publication?
After author Robert Ludlum died, author Brian Freeman
was approached by the Ludlum estate to continue writing the Jason Bourne series.
How do you feel about an author completing or extending another author’s series
post-mortem?
How about taking a dead author’s characters and using
them for entirely new creative fiction? Is that a respectful acquisition, or an
aggressive hijacking?
This reflection on an author’s unfinished work isn’t a
judgment or a justification. We all write on borrowed time. The clock is
ticking. I get it. Sue Grafton never finished writing her murder mystery
alphabet by publishing “Z.”
Writing a full-length novel is a daunting task. It
daunts me every time I start drafting a new one. The spur in my giddy-up is
that I simply can’t fathom doing anything else with my earthly time. Every time
I begin, I stop and wonder: Is it time to hang it up, to find something else to
do to fill my Book of Hours, to quit doing this? Then, as I meditate on the joy the act
of stretching my human imagination to its outermost limits and finding exactly the right
words to add to my latest story brings me, I open my laptop
and begin.
When it comes time for my celebration of life, I want
my family to hand out cupcakes and bookmarks, and perhaps in some future time some
reader will open one of my books and from the other side, I’ll speak again.
Still not convinced that our books are our timeless
legacy? Click this link to hear Dame Judy Dench recite a Shakespearean sonnet
and enjoy hearing The Bard’s voice speak to us with modern relevance from
roughly four hundred and thirty years ago: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t_X1dbO-quI
Great reminders! Thanks, Martha!
ReplyDeleteHi Heather - good morning! The universe gave me a lot to think about with this one.
DeleteI'm not sure how I feel about someone else writing my stories after I'm gone. I guess I won't care because...well...I'll be gone.
ReplyDeleteThought provoking post, Martha. And I'm so sorry about your friend.
Thanks, Annette. Agatha Christie made her decision when she wrote Curtain: Poirot's Last Case. I remember readers were shocked when this book came out!
DeleteWhen an author creates a cast of characters that can successfully live after they are no longer available to write their stories, I'm all for someone else taking up the mantle. From my perspective it's no different than having multiple authors write the Hardy Boys series or employing different screenwriters to create episodes in a great TV series. I do, however, think if an author doesn't want something published, their wish should be granted. I know all the stories about great works that would have been lost, but it's still book piracy to my mind.
ReplyDeleteGood morning, Jim! W. I agree that as long as the author consents it would be similar to George R.R. Martin or Ann Cleves handing off the Game of Thrones or Vera Stanhope story lines to the TV series writers production teams due to time constraints.
DeleteCondolences on the loss of your friend. Your blog raised several questions for me to ponder. Is super involvement in other activities a message that sometimes satisfaction or fulfillment comes from something other than writing? Maybe not writing daily or often reflects one’s true desire ( especially if one has already had a taste of publication). But, if one writes, is the work personal? There have been excellent writers who pick up a series and write in the same style and it works well, but other times it feels like fan fiction with an element missing. Most readers won’t care as the characters continue having adventures, but as a purist, I would rather the series either remain intact or only be continued if there are new adventures that ring true to the original.
ReplyDeleteHi Debra - re: picking up a series, I have a foot in both camps. As long as that was the original author's stated intent, so be it. That said, I picked up a posthumously finished novel and found the new narrative "voice" jarring even though the substitute writer had followed the plot outline. I can also appreciate readers and fans wanted more of their beloved characters. It's a puzzle.
DeleteI'm sorry for your loss.
ReplyDeleteThanks, Margaret. She contributed so much to so many. She will be missed.
DeleteThought to ponder. But for the survivors. We can make our wishes known, but as Annette says, once we're gone, we're gone. And we leave our stories behind.
ReplyDeleteWhat if we write paranormal? Can we come back and protest? Hey! There's a story idea.
DeleteWhat a lovely tribute to your friend, Martha. And I appreciate the philosophical pondering.
ReplyDeleteHi Lori - I had inklings of these ideas during COVID-19. The Celebration of Life really brought them home. Isn't it funny how our life work becomes and reflects our life?
DeleteBoy, what a lot of questions to think about, especially at my age. So sorry about your friend. What a thoughtful life, and her decisions at the end of her life, as well as throughout, shows what an amazing person she was.
ReplyDeleteHi Susan - thank you. Yes, she was an amazing person. I've been blessed knowing many such amazing people in my life.
DeleteThank you for this thoughtful piece, Martha. For the link to Judi Dench reciting the sonnet, too. Off to ponder, then to write.
ReplyDeleteHi Molly - Isn't Dame Judy a hoot. I just love how sassy and robust she is, especially remembering Shakespeare's sonnet at hand. I can't remember where I parked my car. LOL
Delete