Thursday, March 24, 2022

The Worst Writing Advice I've Ever Gotten by Connie Berry


 Aspiring authors usually seek advice from those who have achieved success. Ten years ago, my big question was, “What do I need to fix? JUST TELL ME, AND I’LL DO IT!” Sorry—I was shouting there. The point is, I was open to advice. Too open. Since then, I’ve become a bit more discerning. All advice isn’t good advice. Here are five examples of terrible advice (or potentially terrible advice) new writers often receive:

Just Write—Your Editor Will Correct Your Mistakes

Two things are wrong here. First, unless you’re the next Shakespeare (or the next Lee Child, who claims to write only one draft), you will need to learn a thing or two. Like all skills, novel-writing has a rather steep learning curve. Give yourself time. Second, even if you are a naturally gifted storyteller, submitting a manuscript full of errors will probably earn you a quick “thanks but no thanks.” Why shoot yourself in the foot?

Don’t Use Fancy Words When Plain Ones Will Do

There is a point here: purposely scrolling through the dictionary for words you hope will make you sound intelligent is a terrible idea. If you’re not familiar with a word, chances are you’ll misuse it and embarrass yourself. On the other hand, word choice shouldn’t be based on length but on appropriateness in context. No two words mean exactly the same thing, and some long words are more precise or evocative in their connotation than an almost-equivalent short word. Evocative is a good example. It doesn’t mean the same thing as its synonym moving.

Always Start In Medias Res

The idea here is to hook your reader from the get-go. That’s good. Skip pages and pages of backstory and get right into the conflict. But starting a book with a car chase on a Los Angeles freeway or with someone teetering on the parapet of a thirty-story building in downtown Chicago when the reader has no clue what’s going on is confusing. Why should they care? The idea isn’t to grab readers by the throat and yank them stumbling into the action but to draw them in by giving them someone to care about. Conflict can be internal.

Eliminate All Adverbs

Stephen King said, “The road to hell is paved with adverbs.” Catchy and mostly true. Overusing adverbs is a lazy way to write. It’s better to use strong, precise verbs. But every part of speech has its uses, and adverbs are no exception. Your POV character, for example, might pick up on the way someone says something, not just the words. Or you might want to say, “The trees were nearly bare,” instead of the convoluted, “Only a few leaves still clung to the trees.” And people do use adverbs in speech all the time. Wouldn't some characters say simply, “She’s really beautiful” rather than “She is resplendent in face and form?” 

Write to Please Yourself

Writing to the market usually fails because by the time your story actually gets out there, the market has moved on. However, writing purely to please yourself without regard for modern tastes is fruitless. I’m an English major. I love reading the classics. But few agents today, not to speak of readers, will entertain a modern version of the near-million-word Clarissa. Modern readers have little patience for a long build-up and paragraphs upon paragraphs of description like Leo Tolstoy. You can certainly write to please yourself, but you may be your only reader. Tastes change, and authors who keep up with current trends are smart.

There’s only one more thing to say: no so-called “rules” are absolute. Nevertheless, you have been warned!

What is the worst piece of writing advice you’ve ever received? What is the best?

14 comments:

  1. All those rules about "real" writers write every day or worse, xxxx words every day. It's true that we need to persevere and that butt in the chair is crucial. What is not true is that a process that works for one (or many) will work for you. Experiment until you find what does work for you and stick to it.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I think you have to know the "rules" and why they are the "rules" before you can begin to break them when appropriate. And you can certainly break them.

    Failing to edit and make corrections in your work is just lazy and inconsiderate to whoever will read it. A few writers are quite competent in doing this as they write the first draft; the rest of us need to go back and take a good second (third, fourth, etc.) look.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Learn the rules, abide by the rules, and decide when to break them to enhance the narrative.

    Sentence fragments! Adverbs! More than three named characters in the synopsis! An inadequate compelling reason!

    ReplyDelete
  4. Rules are meant to be followed and broken. If they weren't, some of the greatest inventions and works of art wouldn't exist.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I yelled those actual words into the void plenty when I was trying to figure out what I was doing "wrong" during the querying process -- JUST TELL ME WHAT TO DO AND I'LL DO IT! If only it were that simple. It's like, you should know the "writing rules" but also know how and when to break them. You also have to be open to others yet have the confidence to also listen to yourself. Nothing about this is easy, yet here we are, all writing away and making the difficult trek. Great post.

    ReplyDelete
  6. The adverb rule drives me crazy because, like you stated, people use them. I know some people don't care for Grammarly; however, I do. I just don't always agree with it, and the program gives me the option of trashing.

    ReplyDelete
  7. One of favorite tips came from one of my high school English teachers more than 50 years ago - revision is the key to success. He meant it as a writing tip. It works well in many situations. Thank, Mr. White.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Great blog, Connie! Most of those rules are meant to be learned and then bent judiciously. Is that an adverb :).

    The best advice I ever received, edit, revise, and read the work aloud. It also helps to have great beta readers.

    ReplyDelete
  9. The rule about not ending a sentence with a preposition drives me crazy. Jettison that one.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Not only an instructive blog but also wise advice from in comments. 👏🏼

    ReplyDelete
  11. And never publish before you check even a lonely sentence. LOL.

    "...wise advice from the commentators."

    ReplyDelete
  12. Great post, Connie!

    I think the rule about waiting for your muse to strike can be harmful; if I waited for the ideal inspiration, I might never get to writing!

    ReplyDelete
  13. Great advice Connie. The piece of advice that drove me crazy was "read more". The best advice I have is chose your beta readers carefully. They need to be able to provide critical feedback, but they also need to understand taking six months to provide feedback is not helpful to the writer.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Love this post, Connie. I use fragmented sentences and probably break a few other rules. But first I learned what I was "supposed to do." Besides, as language is constantly changing we writers do too.

    ReplyDelete