I’ve just come off the first phase
of my book tour for Every Last Secret,
and one question that I was asked at almost every event was: “Do you outline
your novels before you write them?”
That seems like a simple yes or no
answer, but with me, it’s a little more complicated. Yes, I outline my novels
before I write them. No, I don’t follow those careful outlines when I write.
The truth is that I’m genetically
incapable of following a pattern or a plan. I can’t tell you how many times
I’ve bought a sewing or knitting or weaving pattern that I wanted to make. Once
I begin, though, I can’t stick to it. I have to tamper with it, to redesign it.
I just can’t do what someone else tells me to do. Perhaps I have a problem with
authority figures. (Do you think?)
This is why I never bother with
patterns when I knit or quilt something anymore. For me, they’re a waste of
time and money. I just go ahead and design my own work “on the needles.”
When it comes to writing novels, I’d
like to change my rebellious attitude, especially now that I have contracts to
fulfill with deadlines, and I’m not writing on spec any longer. So, I sit down
and do some hard thinking about characters’ needs and motivations, about
various actions characters might take, about conflict and pace and things like
that. I write out a scene-by-scene outline for the book.
Then, I sit down to write it. After
a while, I find I can’t go on. I feel there’s something fundamentally wrong with
the book. So I start looking for problems and testing out characters for new
villains. (It’s often the murderer who seems to be wrong.) As I continue to
fiddle and play around with the characters and the scenes and various possible
actions, I inevitably come up with a stronger villain, a more original motive
for murder, and as a nice side benefit, more scenes with powerful conflict
enacted.
My method is hard on the nerves, but
in each case the book that came from all the redesigning is a much stronger book
than the original would have been. So my answer to the question: “Do you
outline your novels before you write them?” is still yes and no. Now, I usually
outline for about 50 pages and write that before outlining the next 50 pages.
That seems to be working for me at this time.
How about you? If you’re a writer,
do you outline your novel before you write it?
I think that it's nearly impossible to write a complete outline. There are so many nuances and quirks that happen during the writing taking the action in new directions. I plot very similarly to you, Linda. I have an overall plan, then I write storyboards for each chapter. Chapter 1--what happens and its function within the overall plot and by which charaters-how I want them shown.
ReplyDeleteAfter that is written, I do the same for Chapter 2. For me it is important that I write the storyboard for Chapter 2 after Chapter 1 is written. What comes out in the actually writing effects the next chapter.
I'm trying to learn to outline more. My current WIP has more detail than usual on paper and it is working but if I go into too much detail I end up feeling like I have already written the book.
ReplyDeleteYour title, Linda, immediately brought to mind the "D" my oldest boy got in art in the 4th grade. I asked about it at parent-teacher conference and the teacher said he wouldn't color per instructions. He didn't color the Halloween pumpkins orange. My son became a very talented artist, but it wasn't until he was in his teens we discovered he was color blind. I'm not sure it had anything to do with the odd colored pumpkins, though, because he was incredibly creative in many ways.
ReplyDeleteI don't outline, but I do have lots of ideas and notes jotted down on where I want the book to go plus the general plot is in my head. Like my son, I tend to let the muse take over and then clean up any loose ends during numerous editing later. I think it's a matter of what works best for each individual. Even though I don't outline, I'd probably still paint my pumpkins orange.
EB, you're so right. Either you change the stuff in chapters 3 & 4 to flow with chapters 1 & 2 right after you write 1 & 2 or completely rewrite them to do that during the first revision.
ReplyDeleteWarren, lots of writers say that--too much detail in outline feels like the book's already written.
ReplyDeleteGloria, I'm with you. It's messier that way, but I think I get more creative alternatives and richness without forcing myself to follow a detailed outline.
ReplyDeleteAnd to your son's teacher--Bah!