Thursday, October 22, 2026

Pea-Soup Fog & Monkey Glands: Ten Reasons Why Victorian England is the Perfect Setting for Murder by Connie Berry


 

In the distance, the bells of St. Mary-Le-Bow toll eleven o’clock. The narrow streets of London’s East End are strangely deserted. Out of the swirling fog comes the clip-clop of horseshoes on cobbles. A carriage appears. I squint, struggling to decipher the gilded crest on the carriage door. From within the passenger compartment, a gloved hand emerges. Wait—is that a gun, or....


I turn the page, my heart in my throat, as the modern world vanishes into the foul-smelling mist. It's London, 1850. Soon a body will turn up--floating in the Thames or sprawled in a brick-walled alleyway. I settle in for another blissful sojourn in Victorian England.

Here are my Top Ten Reasons why Victorian England is the perfect setting for murder:

1. The Famous London Fog

Oh, those thick-as-pea-soup fogs—useful for concealing pick-pockets and cutthroats, handy for the disposal of bodies, and perfect for setting that deliciously sinister atmosphere we crave.

In 1833, Richard Rush of the Court of London wrote: “On the 22nd of the month, accidents occurred all over London....Carriages ran against each other, and persons were knocked down by them at the crossings. The whole gang of thieves seemed to be let loose. After perpetrating their deeds, they eluded detection by darting into the fog...an opake, dingy yellow (from The Dictionary of Victorian London).” Reading about it is healthier than breathing it.

2. Upstairs/Downstairs

Picture a grand house with a full complement of servants. The Victorian social structure provides a treasure trove of tantalizing possibilities—petty rivalries, class struggles, below-stairs’ intrigues, accusations of petty theft, and pretty housemaids to catch the eye of the lord of the manor. And, of course, we need an oh-so-proper butler, a dour housekeeper with a hidden past, a ridiculously handsome footman who captures the heart of the lord’s nubile daughter, and that unfortunate scullery maid who finds the body and screams like a banshee. These are creatures of myth in a world that never existed. Maybe that’s why we love them. 

3. Opium-Eaters & the Lure of Laudanum

A dark doorway in Whitechapel opens into a smoke-filled chamber, the air fetid with sweat, bile, and the bittersweet odor of opium smoke. Bodies lay strewn across low cots or two-tiered bunks, class distinctions forgotten in the communal drug-induced stupor.

In an age when the science of medicine was evolving and the management of pain nearly impossible, opiates became part of life. Laudanum, a mixture of ten percent opium and 90 percent alcohol, has been called “the nineteenth-century aspirin.” Because of its bitter taste, laudanum was often mixed with honey, spices, and brandy—essential when lacing your rival’s seeded cake. 

4. Potent Poisons

Poison was the first choice of many Victorian murderers—especially women. Overbearing husband? Why not soak a little flypaper and add arsenic to his Christmas pudding? Your husband’s bit-on-the-side went and got herself pregnant? A nice box of chocolates laced with strychnine should do the trick.

The strangest case of poisoning in Victorian England has to be Adelaide Bartlett, whose husband, Edwin, died with a large quantity of liquid chloroform in his belly. The question was, how did it get there? No traces were found in his mouth or throat. Without evidence, Adelaide was acquitted. Later, Sir James Paget of St. Bartholomew’s Hospital appealed to her sense of public spirit: “Now that it is all over, she should tell us, in the interest of science, how she did it.” Instead, Adelaide vanished—some say to America.

5. The Village Doctor

What would a Victorian country-house mystery be without a murder? And what would a Victorian country-house murder be without the venerable village doctor? He’s an old friend of the family, naturally, and eager to declare the cause of death in a way guaranteed to cause the family—who haven’t paid him a farthing since before the Queen’s coronation—the least possible fuss. A poisoning is put down to digestive troubles. If the victim is found in his library, shot through the heart, the shooting was obviously a tragic accident whilst cleaning his gun. No forensic examination will be held. In fact, the body will be safely buried before the sleuth has an opportunity to object.

6. Fascination with the Occult

Who killed rich but unpleasant Uncle Nigel? Who would know better than Nigel himself? Let's get out that Ouiji Board.

7. The Age of Exotica

How many ways are there to kill someone? In Victorian England, the possibilities are nearly endless—untraceable poisons added to a glass of port, deadly snakes or spiders tucked beneath the eiderdown. 

During the nineteenth century, amateur adventurers and explorers left England in great numbers to investigate new lands. Tales of strange (and impossible) creatures fired the public imagination—as did sensational claims of miracle cures from exotic substances like mumia (powdered mummies) and strange plants that delivered an electrical shock strong enough to render a man unconscious. Victorian England was particularly mesmerized by Dr. Serge Voronoff, a French doctor of Russian descent, who claimed that monkey testicles (either grafted or injected) could reactivate youthful vigor and even extend life. Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, himself a doctor, used the idea in his 1923 story “The Adventure of the Creeping Man.”

8. What—No Telephone?

One of the benefits of Victorian crime fiction is the convenient lack of modern technology. Someone is found murdered. How are the authorities notified? In nineteenth-century England, you can’t pick up the telephone. You don’t own one, nor do you know anyone who does. Instead, a messenger is sent, probably on bicycle, to alert the local constable, who is probably tucked up in his bed. Perfect. The delay gives you plenty of time to move the body, rearrange the crime scene, and get everyone’s alibi down pat.

9. The Cult of Death

The Victorians were obsessed with death, from anthropomorphic taxidermy to picnicking in cemeteries to memento mori, the weaving the hair of a lost loved one into jewelry.

10. True Crime

Victorian crime fiction has nothing on true crime stories from England in the nineteenth century. George Orwell in “Decline of the English Murder” fantasized about settling down in front of a fire with his pipe and a cup of tea and opening the News of the World. “What is it that you want to read about?” he asked. “Naturally, about a murder.” Jack the Ripper, Dr. Crippen, the Mannings of the Bermondsey Horror, Frederick Seddon, Neill Cream, Mrs. Maybrick—there was nothing the Victorians loved more than a good murder. 


Why do today’s readers still adore the foggy streets of Victorian England, the top-hatted madman, and arsenic-laced blancmange?

It’s elementary, my dear Watson.

[Originally published in CrimeReads]

No comments:

Post a Comment