Friday, November 20, 2026

Thoughts on Jigsaw Puzzles and Subgenres by Nancy L. Eady

I have always liked to do jigsaw puzzles. Until recently, however, because of a lack of space, I have been restricted to putting jigsaw puzzles together through electronic apps rather than the real thing. Our new house has the perfect space to put a puzzle together, and the room to leave the puzzle out until I finish. Our kitchen island is huge, and I don’t have to worry about having to take the puzzle apart when we want to eat at the table. And that fact may indirectly tell you how much I rely on my kitchen for cooking, too.

When we went to the Tennessee mountains in October, I splurged so I could do something I’ve never gotten to do before—assemble a 1000 piece puzzle. At the Smoky Mountains National Park gift shop, I bought a beautiful 1000 piece puzzle of a picture of Cades Cave in the fall. My thinking was it would make the perfect décor for Thanksgiving. At my current rate, however, it will end up being the perfect décor for St. Patrick’s Day or maybe Easter. Doing a little bit of it every day keeps my husband from suggesting I give up on the puzzle so we can have all of the kitchen island back.

I always work a puzzle in the same way. I start with the outside pieces to make the frame, then I work on the inside of the puzzle, trying to work on areas that have distinct colors or features before I move on to the more complicated areas. Writing in a particular mystery subgenre can be similar. The subgenre supplies certain rules the reader can expect to be followed in the work, and the writer’s creativity supplies the imagination and uniqueness to keep every book in a particular subgenre from being the same. For example, if a reader looks to purchase a cozy mystery, they have the right to expect that the book will not be interrupted by the graphic description of the scene a serial killer leaves behind after he/she finishes with their latest victim.

This is a nice and neat metaphor, which was skewed slightly by my current puzzle.

Here is a picture of the puzzle in its current state, which the outside put together as best I can and a few distinctive areas completed:

You will notice, I hope, that my frame is rather choppy. The shape is due to the fact that not all the puzzle pieces in this puzzle are interlocking, which makes the puzzle more challenging.

For example, here is one corner put together:











It looks fairly normal until you look at the same corner slightly deconstructed:









None of the pieces interlock; they just rest against each other to form the corner. It’s kind of a pain in the neck because whenever I bump the puzzle frame, the line straggles off in several directions. I am still debating whether the aggravation is enough to require a roll of removable tape, or whether to tough it out and let the completed puzzle hold everything together.

The non-interlocking pieces mean that the frame in this puzzle doesn’t match the general metaphor for subgenres. Since it has interlocking pieces and non-interlocking pieces in it, I’ll view it as a metaphor applying to those rare works that break subgenre rules, yet still work, or those that blend two subgenres together.

Have you ever tackled a subgenre in your writing and broke the “rules” of that subgenre intentionally? How did it work out for you?