by James M. Jackson
If you have already voted in today’s elections, thank you—assuming, of course, you are a legal voter. Even if you voted for the “wrong” candidates, thank you for helping to maintain a fundamental pillar of our representational democracy—the right to vote as you think best.
The first presidential election for which I was eligible to
vote was 1972. I couldn’t vote in 1968—even though I was eighteen and eligible
to be cannon fodder in the Vietnam War—because in New York, the “age of
majority” was then twenty-one and there was no overriding federal law. That
changed in 1970, when The Voting Rights Act of 1970 lowered the voting age for
federal elections to eighteen.
After the Supreme Court ruled Congress could lower the
voting age for federal elections, but could not for state elections, Congress
passed the 26th Amendment to the Constitution in March 1971. In just
over two months, the required 3/4ths of the states ratified the amendment, and
President Nixon signed it into law on July 5, 1971.
I didn’t recall until I researched this blog that in the 19th
century, it was not uncommon for states and territories to allow noncitizens to
vote. (There were often other requirements, such as property ownership, paying
taxes, or other restrictions to limit voting to “responsible” adults. And in
most states voting privileges applied only to males until passage of the nineteenth
amendment to the Constitution, adopted in 1920.) At the turn of the 20th
century, states began forbidding any noncitizens from voting. Alabama kicked
off the movement in 1901. By the 1928 elections, all states had banned
noncitizen voting. While not legal, not until 1996 did Congress criminalize
noncitizen voting in federal elections.
In 1992, a spark of a movement began when the City of Takoma
Park, Maryland, became the first municipality to restore noncitizen voting for
local elections. The argument leaders gave was that citizenship was irrelevant
when voting for those responsible for delivering local services, such as public
transportation, garbage collection, water, sewage, parks, and recreation, etc.
(And, the Maryland constitution expressly delegated the authority to determine
suffrage requirements for municipal elections to the city charters.)
In 2016, San Francisco voters (Proposition N) gave
noncitizens the right to vote in school board elections. Several other cities
followed soon after. Every attempt to allow noncitizens to vote has gone to
court. Some cities won in court, some lost, and seven states have already
amended their constitutions to forbid noncitizen voting for anything.
Eight more states have similar measures on today’s ballots.
I grew up in a Republican home and counted as my Jackson
ancestors Whigs, then early supporters of the Liberty Party (1840s), Free Soil
Party (early 1850s), and ultimately the Republican party (late 1850s). In grade
school, I was “for” Nixon, and “against” Kennedy. In 1972, I was against Nixon
and for McGovern, and I knew what that meant (including that I was probably the
first of the Jackson clan to ever vote for a Democratic presidential candidate).
Of course, despite my vote, Nixon won in a landslide.
In 1980, I took a “principled” stand, and voted for John B.
Anderson, a liberal Republican Congressman. Across the country, only 5,719,849
other people voted for my candidate. Ronald Reagan crushed President Jimmy
Carter. Even if everyone who had voted for Anderson had voted for Carter, Reagan
would still have trounced Carter, but that was the last of my principled
presidential stands.
I came to realize that as much as I wished for a third party
that represents my views, what mattered was who gets elected. I am better off
choosing the better of the two candidates who could possibly win, and not “send
a message”—especially since the winner doesn’t care about my message.
With primaries, I don’t take that pragmatic approach. I vote
my conscience and hope the winner pays some attention. Hope springs eternal, as
the saying goes.
I have heard some say, “Why bother? My vote doesn’t really
count.” Well, maybe not in most elections. However, if more people who felt
that way did vote, their combined votes might well change things.
Every once in a while, a single vote makes a difference. A
few years back, a school bond referendum was on the ballot and it ended in a
tie. Without my vote, the referendum would have been defeated. The tie meant the
school board could place the referendum on the next ballot (a general election).
With more voters, it received overwhelming approval.
So vote, if you haven’t. Again, thank you if you have.
* * * * *
Notes
1. Liberty Party https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liberty_Party_(United_States,_1840)
2. Timeline of voting rights in the United States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Timeline_of_voting_rights_in_the_United_States
3. Laws permitting noncitizen voting https://ballotpedia.org/Laws_permitting_noncitizens_to_vote_in_the_United_States
No comments:
Post a Comment