Sunday, November 22, 2026

What Scares You? by Annette Dashofy

As I’ve posted about earlier, I’m working on a standalone (two actually) that’s leaning more into the thriller genre than the mysteries that I have written for the last 20+ years. The transition isn’t as easy as you might think. I keep reverting to my default whodunit. 

In an attempt to educate and inspire my thrillerish side, I recently took a masterclass with my good friend and horror author Jonathan Maberry. No, I’m not planning to write horror. I’m too much of a scaredy cat. But his class made me see that the lines between genres are very blurry. He asked one question in particular that stuck with me: 

What scares you? 

No, I’m not going to write an entire novel about spiders. The idea, as I interpreted it, is to think of what scares us as individuals and insert that emotional reaction into our characters. We can do that more literally (example: funneling my inability to swim and resulting fear of drowning into my Dr. Jessie Cameron character in Death By Equine when she slips and falls into an equine therapy swimming pool). Or we can extract what we felt during a terrifying moment and insert the emotional impact into our character when they’re in a different but equally scary situation. 

I knew this. Obviously, I’ve used it in most of my books. But for some reason, I realize I neglected to give my protagonist in my WIP a deep fear. She’s a tough cookie. Perhaps too tough. Prior to Jonathan’s workshop, if you’d asked me what scared her, I’d have given you a list of internal conflicts, not one of which makes her heart race and sweat coat her flesh. Yeah. Big mistake. 

I was aware that something was missing but couldn’t pin down what. 

Now, I know. There has to be a monster (virtual, not Godzilla in this case) lurking in the depths of my protagonist’s psyche.

While this horror model works well in the thriller and suspense genres, it would work equally well in mysteries. Even cozy mysteries. The degree of fear and terror would be tempered to fit the overall feel of the story. 

All good mysteries must contain stakes, consequences for failure. If the protagonist doesn’t catch the killer and can then simply go back to her normal day-to-day life, there’s little to make the reader care. If you add a deep-seated fear to the mix, your reader will have a lot to care about! 

Think about it. As a writer, what moment in your life scared the bejeebers out of you? Can you—or have you—drawn on that memory to make your character’s own fears more vivid? What scares your current WIP’s protagonist? 

And readers, can you recall a character whose fears stand out in your memory?