by Linda Rodriguez
The modern image of pirates today was
formed by the movies, which chose to make them swashbuckling rebel
heroes. In the past, however, pirates were terrifying bandits who
hijacked ships and might or might not kill those on board, but always
stole everything the ship carried and the ship itself, setting any
passengers and crew left alive off in small boats to make their way
to safety (unless they took them to their hideaway and held them for
ransom). Travelers always feared pirates, much more realistically and
viscerally than we now fear terrorists. But since Hollywood made them
romantic heroes at the beginning of the 20th century,
we've forgotten the real horror of piracy.
One would hardly think we could still
equate pirates with romantic leads or endearing but moral scamps, but
Hollywood has such a grip on us that we do. Even though modern
pirates are even more brutal and less romantic than the criminals of
the past. Now, however, they prey on freight or oil being transported
because consumers seldom use ships for serious transportation any
longer. Passenger ships are usually only for shorter vacation cruises
around concentrated coastal locations in highly populated and
protected parts of the world. Consequently, when we hear the term,
“pirate,” we seldom think of these modern-day thugs or the real
criminals that the ancient pirates were—instead we see popular
comic or romantic characters. We even have a day for pretending to
speak as the screenwriters have depicted pirates.
At the link below, you can find
information about modern-day pirates with their machine guns and
rocket launchers.
This is one of the problems I have with
calling book thieves pirates. It allows them to feel like
romantic rebel heroes when they're actually grubby crooks. But
unfortunately, that seems to be the nomenclature in use today, so we
must use it if we wish to be understood.
I recently received a Google alert for
mention of one of my books on a pirate site. This is nothing new,
unfortunately. It happens all too often. This mention, however, was
on a bulletin board on one of the biggest pirate sites. I found a
whole long page of discussion about my book. High praise, glowing
recommendations to other readers—people even said my book had
changed their lives and wanted other books of mine. Unfortunately,
they wanted them for free, also.
As book piracy becomes a huger and
huger problem, more and more writers are dropped in the middle of
their series because their sales have plummeted. For most of them, a
tiny percentage of the illegal free downloads, if actually paid for,
would have saved their series and career. I have no patience with the
folks who say blithely that those people who frequent pirate sites
wouldn't have bought the books anyway. If even a tiny percentage did,
that would make all the difference to those writers—and to the
readers who love those books and have been supporting the series by
buying them or checking them out of their libraries (which buy
books). I also don't want to hear their second excuse, which is that
all content should be free. When you work hard to write that content
over months and years, you can decide to make it free. You have no
right to make that decision about my hard work.
Pirates are thugs and crooks with
nothing romantic, heroic, or comic about them. And the same goes for
the book thieves, as far as I'm concerned.
Unfortunately, there are always those people who want something for nothing. It's the same thing for computer software, music, and videos. People feel that because they haven't physically taken something that they aren't stealing. Wrong. These are the same people who would be appalled if someone accused them of stealing. But that is what they are doing.
ReplyDeleteGoing back to the piracy issue, we recently sailed through the Gulf of Aden and areas known for piracy, and the ship actually held an anti-piracy drill and had guards and equipment on the decks to deter pirates from boarding. It was a bit unnerving.
Romantic portrail of bloody criminals has been going on for a long time. Jesse James was quick and deadly, but even during his time some newspaper accounts made him out to be a hero. It is frustrating as a writer to see my work stolen. I don't know what can be done about it.
ReplyDeleteGrace is right, there will always be people who want something for nothing. Theft of intellectual property has always been an ongoing issue, and it's so much easier these days with the internet and pockets of the world where the pirates can hide.
ReplyDeleteI once ended up flying from Zanzibar to Dar es Salam because pirates suddenly appeared in the waters ion the ferry route, and as Americans we would be prime targets if the ferry were boarded. Flying Impala Air was an adventure in itself, but we made it.
Grace and KM, you both have some first-hand experience then with what the actual fear of piracy is in areas that are vulnerable. Not as romantic, dashing heroes
ReplyDeleteWarren, yes. It's so frustrating not to be able to stop these people from stealing our hard work, and the way so many of them rationalize it to themselves makes it even worse, I think. At least, the professional crooks know and admit they're crooks and don't try to cover over it with high-flown rhetoric about digital freedom, etc.
When we recently attended a Chicago street art fair, photography of the artwork and jewelry was forbidden.
ReplyDeleteTheft is all around us. I fully expect the photos I post on Face Book to be appropriated without crediting me (hint: I never post my best work).
Unless I plan to re-read a book, I borrow it from the library. I order in advance of publication date and sit on a huge waiting list (sometimes 1000+). I also recommend that the library system purchase certain titles. Library e-books and magazines are FREE. No excuse for stealing them.
Margaret, you're absolutely right.I don't know any writers who aren't perfectly happy to have people who can't or don't want to buy their books check them out from the library. There's no real need to steal.
ReplyDeleteI've been very aware of the real pirates that prey on ships because I keep up with the news. I'm also aware of the pirates who steal books. As far as I know, no one has stolen any of mine, but maybe they have and I don't know. I'm thinking that maybe as an indie published writer, I'm less vulnerable, but probably not.
ReplyDeleteYou are right about being happy if people read your books by taking them out of a library. Because I'm indie published most libraries won't buy mine, I donate my books to the local libraries and even to one close to fifty miles away because a 91 year old woman I met told me her library didn't have my books. I gave her my first one, she liked it, so I donated the rest of my series to her library sending them to her so she could read them first.
I think it is reprehensible that anyone would steal a book that an author has slaved over for a long time to make it the best they can, and just as reprehensible to buy such books.
People don't buy the books from pirate sites, Gloria. They download them for free, so all of those people are stealing books.
ReplyDeleteYes, I realize that now. I'd forgotten that part. Sorry.
ReplyDeleteI live near Mystic, CT where there is a wonderful living museum, Mystic Seaport. They do an entire Pirate Weekend - people love dressing up and playing pirate. I understand the allure of the costume, but it's strange that people don't understand that pirates were the Bad Guys. And still are.
ReplyDeleteI'm with you. The term "pirate" carries too much movie glamour and not enough seriousness.
Shari, yeah, the movies have a lot to answer for.
ReplyDeleteI've only just regained power and internet after big storms in KC left large swathes of the city without power. Many thanks to Elaine, who answered my plea by ancient cell phone and posted one of my old posts for me.